Discursive Essay Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Published 21 Jun 2025 · Updated 9 Oct 2026
The most common discursive essay mistakes are repeating points, letting quotations do the thinking, and ending without a clear judgement. This guide sets out ten errors with a fix for each, a weak and a stronger paragraph side by side, and a short checklist.
What examiners say goes wrong
The Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) comments on discursive writing in its 2025 course reports. At Higher, some candidates "explained the same arguments more than once, leading to over long and repetitive pieces". Others stated views without enough argument or evidence.
At National 5, weaker pieces "relied too heavily on ideas or statistics featured in the quoted references". These are school exams, but the same habits lose marks in college and university essays.
Ten common discursive essay mistakes
Each one is explained below with its fix. They cover planning, evidence, structure, endings and tone, so check each one.
- Repeating a point in new words
- Making a claim with no evidence
- Letting quotations replace your own analysis
- Warming up for too long in the introduction
- Writing for and against blocks that never meet
- Putting two points in one paragraph
- Treating the other side as a weak target
- Adding new points in the conclusion
- Sitting on the fence at the end
- Using a tone that is too casual or too emotional
Discursive essay tips
Most of the ten mistakes disappear with better planning and a few habits while you draft. These four fixes cover the most common faults.
Fix repetition with a numbered point list
Before you write, list your points in the order you will use them. Cross out any two that make the same claim. If a point appears twice in your plan, it will appear twice in your essay.
Fix weak evidence with a three-part sentence
Write the claim, then the evidence, then what it shows. For example: schools differ widely (claim), a named survey reports the range (evidence), so one rule may not suit every school (what it shows).
Keep your own voice beside your sources
SQA advises that discursive writing should not be "only a compilation of ideas contained in quoted or referenced sources". After every quotation, add a sentence that says what you make of it.
Plan your time in an exam
Divide the time before you start. In a 45-minute task you might allow five minutes to plan, 35 to write and five to check. Leave room for a short conclusion, even if a middle paragraph is unfinished.
Discursive essay introduction
An introduction has one job: to show the reader the question and where your essay is heading. Aberystwyth University describes it as telling the reader how you will tackle the question.
Mistake: a long warm-up
Opening with a general sentence about society, then another, delays the point. Name the issue in your first or second sentence and say why people disagree about it.
Mistake: no line of thought
If the reader finishes your introduction unsure what you will weigh up, the plan is missing. State the main views you will compare and the judgement you are working towards.
Mistake: promising what you do not deliver
If the introduction says you will look at cost, safety and fairness, each needs a paragraph. Write the introduction last, once you know what the body contains.
Discursive essay structure
Structure mistakes make good ideas hard to follow. Our full guide on how to write a discursive essay shows the layouts. These are the faults to look for.
Mistake: for and against blocks that never meet
Three paragraphs for, then three against, with no comparison, leave the reader to do the weighing. Add a sentence that sets one side against the other, such as which point carries more weight and why.
Mistake: two points in one paragraph
A paragraph that argues two ideas becomes long and loses focus. Split it, and open each part with a topic sentence. Our guide to sentences in a paragraph helps you judge length.
Mistake: treating the other side unfairly
State the opposing view as its supporters would, then explain with evidence why you find it less convincing. Our discussion essay guide covers balance in more depth.
Discursive essay conclusion
Aberystwyth University and the University of Cumbria both advise against adding new points here. A conclusion should pull the argument together and answer the question.
Mistake: new points at the end
A fresh argument in the last paragraph has no evidence behind it and confuses the reader. If it matters, move it into the body. If it does not, cut it.
Mistake: sitting on the fence
"There are good arguments on both sides" is not a judgement. Say which side is stronger, or why the answer depends on circumstances, and give your main reason.
Mistake: a conclusion that contradicts the body
Write your final judgement in note form during planning. Then check each paragraph moves towards it.
Discursive essay example
This invented paragraph answers the question: should the school day start later for teenagers? It shows how the same idea reads before and after editing.
| Version | Paragraph |
|---|---|
| Weak | Everybody knows teenagers are tired, so school should start later. It is obviously better. Some people disagree but they are wrong. |
| Problems | No evidence. A claim that "everybody knows". The opposing view is dismissed. No link to the next point. |
| Stronger | One argument for a later start is sleep. A named study of sleep and attendance (add your own source) suggests tired students miss more lessons. Critics point to transport and childcare, which are real costs. Even so, those problems can be planned for, which makes sleep the stronger concern. |
Compare the two paragraphs. The stronger version names its evidence, admits the cost on the other side, and ends with a judgement that links back to the question.
Tone and wording mistakes
Discursive writing is formal but readable. Strong feeling, slang and absolute words make a balanced argument look biased.
| Too casual or too strong | Why it weakens the essay | More careful wording |
|---|---|---|
| Honestly, it is a total no-brainer. | Dismisses the other side | There is a strong case for the change. |
| This proves that schools are failing. | One source rarely proves anything | This suggests that many schools struggle. |
| Everyone knows it is bad. | No evidence, no named group | Several studies report harm, although results differ. |
| Also... also... also... | Repeated link word | In addition; however; as a result. |
Words such as "suggests" and "may" show you know the evidence has limits.
Check your essay for mistakes
Read your draft in four passes. Each pass looks for one type of fault, so you never try to spot everything at once, which is hard to do.
- Pass 1: read only the first sentence of each paragraph. Do they build an argument?
- Pass 2: highlight the evidence in each paragraph. Add support wherever a paragraph has none.
- Pass 3: read the introduction and conclusion together. Do they agree?
- Pass 4: read aloud for tone, repeated words and long sentences. A grammar checker can catch slips.
Need feedback on your essay?
Our specialists give written feedback on your draft, and you write the final version yourself. See how it works for the process.
Related guides
- How to write a discursive essay
- How to write a discussion essay
- Grammar checker
- How many words in a paragraph
Sources
- SQA (2025) Course report 2025: Higher English
- SQA (2025) Course report 2025: National 5 English
- Aberystwyth University: How to structure your essay
- University of Cumbria: Structuring a conclusion
Frequently asked questions
What are common mistakes in discursive essays?
Repeating points, claims without evidence, quotations without analysis, unfair treatment of the other side and a conclusion that gives no judgement.
How do you structure a discursive essay?
Use an introduction that frames the issue, body paragraphs that each make one point with evidence, and a conclusion that weighs the views and answers the question.
Should a discursive essay be balanced?
Usually yes. Show the strongest case for each side fairly. Some tasks, such as "Do you agree?", expect your own position from the start.
Can I use "I" in a discursive essay?
Often yes, sparingly, especially in school work. At university, check your module guide, because some departments prefer the third person.
How long should the introduction be?
Keep it short, often one short paragraph that frames the issue and previews your line of thought. Your word count and marking criteria decide the exact length.
Is it a mistake to give my opinion?
No, if the task allows it. Give it after weighing the evidence, and support it with reasons rather than strong feelings.
How many sources do I need?
It depends on the task and level. Aim for at least one reliable source per main point, and check your marking criteria.
