How to Write a Discussion Essay: Step-by-Step Guide

Published 29 Jul 2025 · Updated 9 Oct 2026
A discussion essay looks at an issue from more than one side and ends with your reasoned view. You plan both sides, present each fairly, weigh the evidence and conclude. This guide gives the steps, a worked example and a word-count split.
Get feedback on your essay plan
What is a discussion essay?
Also called a 'for and against' essay, it needs balance. You give each side fair space, keep facts apart from opinion and usually state which side you favour at the end.
Questions come in three common forms.
- A direction, such as 'Examine the arguments for and against...'
- A statement followed by 'Discuss'
- A question about advantages and disadvantages
Discussion essay structure
The University of York advises framing an essay with an introduction and a conclusion, with one main idea in each paragraph. For this essay, that gives five parts.
- Introduction: context, key terms and your thesis
- Arguments for, in one or more paragraphs
- Arguments against, in one or more paragraphs
- Weighing: which side is stronger, and when
- Conclusion: your judgement and its implication
Step 1: Unpick the question
Underline the task word, the topic and any limit, such as a country or time period. Then decide what a fair answer must cover. Write the question at the top of your plan and check each paragraph against it.
Spot the task word
'Discuss', 'consider' and 'to what extent' all ask for balance. 'Evaluate' asks for a judgement about quality or value. If the wording is unclear, ask your tutor which they expect.
Step 2: Plan both sides
Draw two columns. List three or four points for each side, and next to each point note one source you could cite. Cross out weak points. Put the strongest ideas first, as markers read the opening of each section most closely.
- Three or four points per side, each with a source
- One counterpoint you can answer on each side
- A draft thesis you can change after weighing
- A rough word budget for every part
Make the sides equal
Aim for evidence of similar quality on each side. If one side rests on research and the other on opinion, say so. Do not build a weak opposing view just to knock it down.
Step 3: Write the introduction
Give brief context, define any key term and state your thesis. A good thesis names what you will weigh and hints at your view.
Thesis pattern
Try: 'This essay weighs [benefit] against [risk] and argues that [your view] because [reason].' Our thesis statement generator can help you test your wording.
Step 4: Write balanced body paragraphs
Open each paragraph with a topic sentence, add evidence, explain it and link back to the question. Our guide to how many sentences are in a paragraph shows how long each should be.
Use cautious language
York's guide suggests cautious wording where the evidence allows. Write 'suggests' or 'is likely to' instead of 'proves', and avoid sweeping words such as 'always' or 'everyone'.
Step 5: Weigh the evidence and conclude
Compare the sides directly in a short section before the conclusion. Say which points are stronger and why. Then state your judgement, with no new evidence.
What the conclusion needs
Sum up the main points on each side, give your view, and end with a recommendation or implication. Need a second pair of eyes? See our conclusion writing help.
Phrases that keep the balance
Signpost each move so the reader can follow your weighing. Use these as prompts, in your own words.
- Adding a point: 'A further argument is that...'
- Turning to the other side: 'Opponents, however, argue that...'
- Comparing: 'The evidence for this view is stronger because...'
- Qualifying: 'This holds mainly when...'
- Concluding: 'Taken together, the evidence suggests...'
Discussion essay example
This invented outline answers: 'Discuss whether universities should move most lectures online.' It is a plan, not a model answer, and each point needs a real source.
| Part | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Introduction | Many courses now record lectures. Thesis: online delivery gains flexibility but loses discussion, so a blended model is the fairest balance. |
| For | Commuters, carers and part-time students gain flexibility. Recordings help revision. |
| Against | Peer contact and questions suffer. Home study conditions are uneven. |
| Weighing | Flexibility matters most for large lectures. Discussion matters most in seminars. |
| Conclusion | Keep seminars on campus and move large lectures online, with support for students who need it. |
How long is an essay?
Your module brief sets the length, so follow it. This split for a 1,500-word essay is a starting point only.
| Part | Words | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | 150 | 10% |
| Arguments for | 450 | 30% |
| Arguments against | 450 | 30% |
| Weighing | 300 | 20% |
| Conclusion | 150 | 10% |
Check the total with our word counter for essays before you submit.
How to write an explanatory essay
An explanatory essay explains a topic or process clearly and does not weigh opposing views. Follow your brief, because some departments use the terms loosely.
| Feature | Explanatory essay | Discussion essay |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Explain how or why | Weigh views and judge |
| Sides | Usually one clear account | Two or more, treated fairly |
| Ending | Summary of the explanation | Reasoned judgement |
If your question says 'discursive', read our guide to the discursive essay too.
Common mistakes
- Describing both sides without judging either
- Giving one side far more space
- Hiding your view until it is unclear
- Adding new evidence in the conclusion
- Quoting at length with no analysis, which York warns against
More in our list of discursive essay mistakes.
Check your essay before you submit
- Does each paragraph make one point and link to the question?
- Is every claim supported and cited? Use our Harvard referencing generator.
- Is your judgement clear and fair to both sides?
- Is the wording your own? Run our plagiarism checker.
Need feedback on your draft?
Our specialists give written feedback on structure, balance and referencing, and you write the final version yourself. See how it works or ask about essay editing.
Related guides
- How to write a discursive essay
- Discursive essay mistakes
- How many sentences are in a paragraph
- Thesis statement generator
Sources
- University of York, Structuring an essay
- EAP Foundation, Discussion essays
Frequently asked questions
What is a discussion essay?
An essay that examines an issue from different sides, weighs the evidence and reaches a reasoned conclusion. It is also called a 'for and against' essay.
How do you structure a discussion essay?
Use an introduction, arguments for, arguments against, a weighing section and a conclusion. Longer essays add paragraphs on each side.
How do you start a discussion essay?
Give brief context, define key terms and state a thesis that says what you will weigh. Avoid sweeping opening statements.
How many paragraphs should it have?
There is no fixed number. A short essay may have five, while longer ones add paragraphs for each side. Match the length to your brief.
How long is a discussion essay?
Your module brief sets the length. A common plan gives about 30% of the words to each side and 20% to weighing. See the split above.
Should I give my own opinion?
Usually yes, at the end, based on the evidence you discussed. Check your brief, as some tutors want a neutral conclusion.
What is the difference between discussion and argumentative essays?
A discussion essay gives sides fair weight before judging. An argumentative essay defends one position throughout.
